Office Broker Commission and Your Cost of Finding a Tenant: What a Direct Marketplace Changes
An operator's cost of finding a tenant includes broker commission, marketing, staff time and the months an office stands empty while it is marketed. Working it out per signed deal shows which channels pay for themselves, and what a direct marketplace changes.
Reviewed on
Why Work Out What Each Occupier Costs to Win?
Most operators know their occupancy rate to the decimal point. Fewer know what each new occupier actually cost to win. Yet that figure decides how much of the first year's income is left once a deal is signed, and which channels deserve more of your time. This guide sets out how to work it out and what a direct marketplace changes. It is general guidance, not financial advice.
What Goes Into the Cost of Finding a Tenant?
Five things, roughly:
- Commission paid to brokers and agents on the deals they introduce.
- Fees to listing sites and marketplaces, whether fixed or per deal.
- Marketing spend: your website, advertising, photography and tours.
- Staff time spent on enquiries, viewings, proposals and negotiation, including on the deals that never sign.
- The income lost while the office stands empty, and any rent free period or discount given to close.
How Do Brokers Charge Operators?
In the London flexible office market, brokers who are free to occupiers are paid by the operator. Brokers say so on their own sites: one says it is “paid a commission by the office provider when a deal completes”[1], and another tells occupiers that operators pay it[2]. A London operator's own guide to agents notes that a broker earns commission from the space it leases[3]. The rate is set in each operator's agreement with each broker and is rarely published, so the only reliable figure is the one in your own contracts.
How Do You Work Out the Cost per Signed Deal?
Pick a period, such as the last year. Add up everything you spent on finding occupiers in that period, across all five categories. Divide by the number of agreements signed. Then repeat the sum channel by channel, counting only the deals each channel brought in. The results are often surprising. A channel with a high fee per deal can still be cheap if it brings well matched occupiers who sign quickly, and a channel with no fee can be expensive if it eats staff time.
Why Does the Empty Month Matter So Much?
Because it is usually the largest cost and the least visible. JLL describes managed offices as a way for landlords to convert idle space faster and mitigate capital risk[4]. Every month an office stands empty is income that can never be recovered, so any channel that shortens the gap between occupiers is worth more than its fee alone suggests.
What Does a Direct Marketplace Change?
On a direct marketplace the occupier finds your office, enquires and arranges a viewing with you, and you negotiate with them yourself. You keep the relationship from the first message. There is no broker between you, so there is no broker commission on that deal. In exchange, you do the work a broker would have done: answering promptly, running the viewing and handling the negotiation. Your listing also has to do more of the selling, so its photographs, prices and availability need to be right.
What Does a Direct Marketplace Charge Operators?
District (district-hq.com), a managed office marketplace for London, is one direct marketplace. There is no upfront listing or subscription charge. District charges the operator a success fee of 3 percent of the chargeable workspace value, plus VAT where applicable. The value is the recurring workspace charges for the committed period, capped at the first 12 months, after discounts and rent free periods, and excluding VAT and refundable deposits. The fee is earned once, only when the agreement is unconditional, occupation has started and the operator has received the first non refundable workspace payment. District does not charge occupiers for searching, enquiring or arranging viewings.
Twelve months at 10,000 pounds a month gives a fee of 3,600 pounds. For a two-year agreement, the second year is outside the fee calculation. To compare, apply the terms of your own broker agreements to the same deals.
Does Listing on a Direct Marketplace Mean Leaving Brokers?
No. Brokers bring occupiers you would not otherwise meet, and many operators will keep working with them. Participation is non-exclusive, so an operator can keep using other marketplaces and brokers, with District's agreed introduction rights preserved for the enquiries it brings. The point of measuring cost per deal is to know what each channel is worth, not to drop any of them on principle.
What Should You Track From Now On?
For every enquiry, record where it came from, whether it led to a viewing, whether it signed, and the value and term of the agreement. After a few months you will have a cost per deal for each channel, a conversion rate from enquiry to signature, and a clear view of how long offices stand empty between occupiers. Those three numbers make the next pricing and marketing decision much easier.
The aim is simple: know what each occupier costs to win, and put your effort where the cost is lowest for the quality of occupier you want.
Sources
- My New HQ homepage, My New HQ. Read on .
- Tally Workspace homepage, Tally Workspace. Read on .
- Office rental agency or direct: which is best when?, Workspace Group. Read on .
- Managed offices: from void to value, JLL. Read on .